ESMValTool logo.

Equilibrium Climate Sensitivity (ECS)

Calculate Equilibrium Climate Sensitivity (ECS) using linear regression following Gregory et al. (2004).

Authors

Maintainers

Projects

References

Cmip6

Calculate ECS for all available CMIP6 models.

Cmip6: Ecs

Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model ACCESS-CM2 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model ACCESS-CM2 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model ACCESS-ESM1-5 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model ACCESS-ESM1-5 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model AWI-CM-1-1-MR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model AWI-CM-1-1-MR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model BCC-CSM2-MR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model BCC-CSM2-MR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model BCC-ESM1 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model BCC-ESM1 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CAMS-CSM1-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CAMS-CSM1-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CESM2-FV2 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CESM2-FV2 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CESM2-WACCM-FV2 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CESM2-WACCM-FV2 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CESM2-WACCM (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CESM2-WACCM (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CESM2 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CESM2 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CMCC-CM2-SR5 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CMCC-CM2-SR5 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CNRM-CM6-1-HR (ensemble member r1i1p1f2). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CNRM-CM6-1-HR (ensemble member r1i1p1f2). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CNRM-CM6-1 (ensemble member r1i1p1f2). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CNRM-CM6-1 (ensemble member r1i1p1f2). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CNRM-ESM2-1 (ensemble member r1i1p1f2). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CNRM-ESM2-1 (ensemble member r1i1p1f2). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CanESM5 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CanESM5 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model E3SM-1-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model E3SM-1-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model EC-Earth3-Veg (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model EC-Earth3-Veg (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model FGOALS-f3-L (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model FGOALS-f3-L (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model FGOALS-g3 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model FGOALS-g3 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model GISS-E2-1-G (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model GISS-E2-1-G (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model GISS-E2-1-H (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model GISS-E2-1-H (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model HadGEM3-GC31-LL (ensemble member r1i1p1f3). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model HadGEM3-GC31-LL (ensemble member r1i1p1f3). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model HadGEM3-GC31-MM (ensemble member r1i1p1f3). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model HadGEM3-GC31-MM (ensemble member r1i1p1f3). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model INM-CM4-8 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model INM-CM4-8 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model INM-CM5-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model INM-CM5-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model IPSL-CM6A-LR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model IPSL-CM6A-LR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model KACE-1-0-G (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model KACE-1-0-G (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MCM-UA-1-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MCM-UA-1-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MIROC-ES2L (ensemble member r1i1p1f2). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MIROC-ES2L (ensemble member r1i1p1f2). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MIROC6 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MIROC6 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MPI-ESM-1-2-HAM (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MPI-ESM-1-2-HAM (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MPI-ESM1-2-HR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MPI-ESM1-2-HR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MPI-ESM1-2-LR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MPI-ESM1-2-LR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MRI-ESM2-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MRI-ESM2-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model NESM3 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model NESM3 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model SAM0-UNICON (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model SAM0-UNICON (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model TaiESM1 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.
Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model TaiESM1 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance

Data files

  • Equilibrium Climate Sensitivity (Gregory method) for multiple climate models. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model ACCESS-CM2 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model ACCESS-ESM1-5 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model AWI-CM-1-1-MR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model BCC-CSM2-MR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model BCC-ESM1 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CAMS-CSM1-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CESM2-FV2 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CESM2-WACCM-FV2 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CESM2-WACCM (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CESM2 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CMCC-CM2-SR5 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CNRM-CM6-1-HR (ensemble member r1i1p1f2). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CNRM-CM6-1 (ensemble member r1i1p1f2). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CNRM-ESM2-1 (ensemble member r1i1p1f2). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model CanESM5 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model E3SM-1-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model EC-Earth3-Veg (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model FGOALS-f3-L (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model FGOALS-g3 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model GISS-E2-1-G (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model GISS-E2-1-H (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model HadGEM3-GC31-LL (ensemble member r1i1p1f3). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model HadGEM3-GC31-MM (ensemble member r1i1p1f3). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model INM-CM4-8 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model INM-CM5-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model IPSL-CM6A-LR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model KACE-1-0-G (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MCM-UA-1-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MIROC-ES2L (ensemble member r1i1p1f2). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MIROC6 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MPI-ESM-1-2-HAM (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MPI-ESM1-2-HR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MPI-ESM1-2-LR (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model MRI-ESM2-0 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model NESM3 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model SAM0-UNICON (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Global annual mean top of the atmosphere (TOA) net radiation flux anomaly N vs. global annual mean near-surface air temperature anomaly ΔT for the first 20 years (blue circles) and last 130 years (orange circles) of the abrupt 4x CO2 experiment for model TaiESM1 (ensemble member r1i1p1f1). Anomalies are calculated relative to a pre-industrial control simulation of the same model. The solid lines correspond to ordinary linear regressions between N and ΔT for the different years (the black lines corresponds to all years). In the legend, R2 corresponds to the coefficient of determination of the linear regressions. The equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) is estimated as the x-intercept of the linear regressions (interception of the solid and dashed lines) divided by 2. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance
  • Climate Feedback Parameter for multiple climate models. | download | references | extra data citation | provenance

Cmip6: Scatterplot

Equilibrium Climate Sensitivity (Gregory method) for CMIP6 for multiple datasets.
Equilibrium Climate Sensitivity (Gregory method) for CMIP6 for multiple datasets.

download | references | extra data citation | provenance

Data files

Files

main_log.txt | main_log_debug.txt | recipe_ecs_cmip6_multi.yml | figures | data